After Three Years, the Truth Is Revealed
It has been three years since the Results of the Results of the 2023 NFL Draft took place.
For NFL scouts, this time frame is important because it allows for a more accurate evaluation of a draft class. Players grow, injuries occur, and some players who were initially seen as busts turn out to need more time to develop. Others, who were overlooked, may emerge as standout performers in later rounds.
Now, it is clear which teams succeeded and which failed in the Results of the 2023 NFL Draft.
Some teams looked like they had made smart decisions, while others made the draft seem like a farce. The contrast between these outcomes is substantial.
The Gold Standards: Seattle and Los Angeles
Two franchises have benefited the most from the Results of the 2023 NFL Draft: the Seattle Seahawks and the Los Angeles Rams.
Both deserve high marks for their performances.
The Seattle Seahawks entered the draft holding two first-round selections and used them to draft cornerback Devon Witherspoon and wide receiver Jaxon Smith- Njigba, both extensively regarded as elite bents at their separate positions.
That is a strong start. However, the Seahawks’ work didn’t stop there. Three additional players from that draft became starters in 2026. The Results of the 2023 NFL Draft was instrumental in building a core for a potential Super Bowl-winning team.
Los Angeles has a unique story of its own.
The team selected 14 Results of the 2023 NFL Draft players, with five becoming starters. Puka Nacua, a fifth-round pick, was overlooked by most of the league but has since emerged as one of the best offensive players in the NFL. Other standout players include starting guard Steve Avila, defensive linemen Byron Young and Kobie Turner, and tackle Warren McClendon. All of them became key contributors. This demonstrates how effective roster construction can be across various draft rounds.
The Quiet Achievers
Several other teams have earned recognition for their performance in the 2023 NFL Draft.
The Detroit Lions had a clear plan and executed it well.
Selecting running back Jahmyr Gibbs in the first round was controversial due to the position’s typical selection order. However, Gibbs has silenced his critics. The addition of Jack Campbell, Sam LaPorta, and Brian Branch has only strengthened the case. Injuries affected the schedule, but the talent is undeniable. The Lions earned an A.
The Philadelphia Eagles built a strong foundation through the Results of the Results of the 2023 NFL Draft
The defensive duo of Jalen Carter and Nolan Smith, selected in the first round, helped the Eagles win a Super Bowl. A seventh-round selection, Moro Ojomo, remains on the roster. Six out of seven of their picks are still with the team three years later. This serves as a strong indication of success.
The Jacksonville Jaguars may not be the most talked about in the discussion, but they deserve praise for their draft strategy.
They selected 13 players, with five projected to be starters. Antonio Johnson, taken in the fifth round, and Parker Washington, selected in the sixth, have both become breakout stars in 2025. The ability to accumulate picks through trades and identify quality starters is not easy. The Jaguars showed they understand how to do it.
The Houston Texans made bold moves in the Results of the 2023 NFL Draft, and most of their selections paid off. Edge rusher Will Anderson Jr., selected with the third overall pick after trading up, has quickly become one of the best edge defenders in the league. Quarterback C.J. Stroud, selected after another trade-up, had an impressive rookie season. If Stroud continues this level of performance, the draft could be considered one of the most successful in recent memory.
Where It All Went Wrong
Every team that succeeded has a counterpart that failed.
The Dallas Cowboys were given an A rating before the draft, but their performance was nothing short of a failure.
Their first-round pick, defensive tackle Mazi Smith, was traded to the New York Jets after not contributing. Their second-round selection, tight end Luke Schoonmaker, remains a backup. Linebacker DeMarvion Overshown showed promise until a severe knee injury ended his career. None of the remaining five picks are still with the team. This represents a complete loss of draft value. Giving them an F seems too kind.
The Las Vegas Raiders also had a disappointing draft.
Their first-round pick, Tyree Wilson, was unproductive and was sent to the Saints for a fifth-round pick. Their second-round selection, Michael Mayer, is solid but lacks distinction. The best player from the class, Tre Tucker, is an average performer. Trading a headliner away for nothing is damaging to both morale and draft evaluation.
The Carolina Panthers made a big move by selecting quarterback Bryce Young.
Three years later, the results are still unclear. Young has shown flashes of brilliance, but he has not yet demonstrated consistent performance. If he develops into a future Hall of Famer, the trade will be justified. Otherwise, it may be one of the worst decisions in the last decade for a struggling franchise.
What the NFL Draft 2023 Results Really Mean
Looking at the overall results of the Results of the 2023 NFL Draft, one pattern becomes clear: the teams that did well did not rely on just one first-round pick.
They succeeded through selections in the third, fourth, and fifth rounds.
Players like Puka Nacua, De’Von Achane, Chase Brown, Antonio Johnson, and Parker Washington emerged as standouts in later rounds.
These late-round hits are what distinguish a good draft from a great one. Anyone can find a star in the first round, but the best teams find the hidden gems that others overlook. This is what makes the NFL Draft a true test of scouting and talent evaluation.
Click here: Spurs San Antonio’s Road to the Conference Finals Is No Accident
